A growing range of private actors, from industry groups to civil society organizations, are trying to shape the standards that govern the ethical implications of artificial intelligence. In a new article in the Journal of European Public Policy’s special issue on the governance of AI, Graeme Auld, Ashley Casovan, Benjamin Faveri and I draw on lessons from other private governance initiatives, such as certification programs, to map three pathways along which these actors interact with states: opposing and fending them off, engaging and pushing them, or leading and inspiring them. We find that today’s AI ethics standards space is dominated by the “engage and push” pathway, which may advantage first-mover standards. We also identify the forces that could shift that balance, including focusing events around AI failures and the growth of sector-specific standards. For governments, the findings raise important questions about who is setting the rules for AI, and how public institutions can ensure those rules serve the public interest.

Read the article